Best Pit Turkey Sandwiches in Maryland

October 7, 2023

Beefalo Bob’s has been on my list for what seems like ages! I finallllly got to check it out with my bf, and the food did NOT disappoint. So, here’s everything we got:

▪️Dinner platter ($13.49): a reg sandwich (pit turkey) + two sides. We got their boardwalk style fries & collard greens. And for my sammie, I got my pit turkey with spicy BBQ sauce! Next time, I’m definitely going to add LTO as well. Everything was fantastic, and this may have been one of the best turkey sandwiches I’ve ever had. 10/10 recommend. Sides were fire, too. I LOVE that I can get my fry fix without having to make the trip down to OC.
▪️Pit Beef Sandwich (reg for $9.49): I got mine with onions, s&p, and tiger sauce. I got my meat rare, but you can get whatever temp you’d like. This was really solid, but I definitely enjoyed the turkey more.

Note: I was high key SHOOKETH by how much meat they gave! They’re very heavy-handed so expect serious bang for your buck. It was so much, I was taking some out to save for another sandwich at home, lol. As for dine-in, they have a few tables inside, but this is def more of a carryout spot (hence the name 😅).

ALSO, if you like spicy, ask for a side of their inferno sauce. It’s extremely flavorful, and pretty dang spicy! To be honest, I wasn’t expecting this kind of heat so maybe have a glass of milk nearby if you’re not sure you can handle it!

AND ONE MORE THING, they also sell doggy bags for your furbaby so you may want to get something for your floof while you’re there. I would’ve loved to get some for Daisy but she’s diabetic so I need to be extra careful with what I feed her, *sniffles*.

If you’re making a full day of Pasadena, Yuki Luxury Head Spa is a great way to treat yourself before or after the food run.

Have you guys been to Beefalo Bob’s yet? What’s your favorite pit beef/pit turkey spot in the area? Let me know by leaving a comment below, Nomsters.

If you’re in South County, Bayside Bull in Edgewater is worth adding to the rotation — their pit beef and pit ham both come on kaiser rolls with tiger sauce at a walk-up counter, and every sandwich is $9.93.

📍107 Mountain Rd, Pasadena, MD

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Like 0
Close
Copyright © 2026 Nomtastic Kim. All rights reserved.
Close