When it comes to finding the best cheesesteak in Howard County, my answer is easy: Eataliano Market & Deli in Columbia. This has been my go-to spot for years, not just for cheesesteaks, but for consistently delicious Italian comfort food across the board. If you haven’t been yet, this is absolutely a run-don’t-walk situation.
Full transparency here – NOM Digital does handle their social media, BUT I promise this recommendation isn’t biased. If anything, this visit just reaffirmed why I’ve loved this place for so long. It was actually Deke’s first time trying Eataliano, and his reaction said everything. After a few bites, he looked at me and said, “I would definitely seek this place out.” That’s when you know a cheesesteak is doing something right.
Their cheesesteaks are exactly what you want when the craving hits. They’re generously packed, well seasoned, and cooked just right, with bread that holds everything together without falling apart. Deke ordered his with long hots, which added the perfect amount of heat and flavor. If you like a little spice, that’s definitely the move. I decided to switch things up and tried their Caprese sub instead, which was fresh and solid, but let’s be real, I’ll be getting the cheesesteak again next time. Some orders just can’t be replaced.
One of the things that really sets Eat Italiano apart is that it’s more than just a sandwich spot. Their pizza is also really good, and they frequently run a buy-one-get-one-free deal on Uber Eats, which is always risky knowledge to have. They also have a small Italian market inside with tons of goodies, making it very easy to walk out with more than you planned on buying.
They’re the kind of place you’ll want to keep in your regular rotation. It works just as well for a quick lunch as it does for an easy dinner or takeout night when you want something satisfying without overthinking it.
If you’re on the hunt for the best cheesesteak in Howard County, this spot absolutely deserves to be at the top of your list. Whether it’s your first visit or your fifteenth, I promise it’s one of those places you’ll keep coming back to…most likely for that cheesesteak.
📍 5325 Phelps Luck Dr, Columbia, MD
⏰ Su-Th 10-9:30PM, Fr-Sa 10-10:30PM
For more on yum eats in Columbia, make sure you check out this tab!